The Medical Imaging & Technology Alliance (MITA) has called for the U.S. FDA to strengthen its guidance on medical device remanufacturing and enforce the regulatory requirements associated with remanufacturing activities, including implementation of a quality management system, federal registration, and reporting of adverse events.
“Central to the FDA protecting patient safety as pertains to remanufacturing, the agency needs to know who these companies are and hold them accountable for their activities. Otherwise, a significant number of remanufacturing activities may never be known to the FDA, creating a major public health concern,” says Patrick Hope, MITA executive director.
According to the letter, “uncontrolled remanufacturing activities that escape appropriate oversight present a significant risk of:”
- Performance or safety events, leading to misdiagnosis, mistreatment, or even injury
- Creating uncleared, unapproved, adulterated, or otherwise non-conforming devices
- Allowing non-conforming devices to remain in use
- Reintroducing non-conforming devices into interstate commerce
“In its 2018 report, the FDA concluded that a majority of adverse events reported to the agency thought to be related to servicing — including those contributing to deaths—actually pertained to remanufacturing, an activity regulated comparably to manufacturing,” adds Hope. “This conclusion shows that entities performing servicing often cross into remanufacturing, which is explicitly regulated by the FDA. Therefore, the FDA needs to enforce proper oversight over servicers whose remanufacturing activities have previously escaped notice, ensuring devices work safely and effectively for their intended use.”
In addition to the risk-based approach outlined in the draft guidance, MITA also endorsed requiring all medical device servicers to adopt relevant quality management systems already governing original equipment manufacturers. “Performance of servicing and remanufacturing activities within an appropriate quality management system by properly trained technicians using qualified, properly sourced parts greatly reduces the risk of harm to the patient or operator and objectively maintains the performance of the device,” according to the MITA letter. (Read it here.)
MITA also advocates for removing the product labeling recommendations, noting the policy outlined in the labeling section of the draft guidance would eliminate OEM intellectual property protections and allow for uncontrolled wide release of proprietary servicing materials, creating an irrevocable loss of trade secret protection for manufacturers.
Please share your reactions to this letter in the comments section.