A Claroty analysis found that more than 95% of gaming consoles identified on healthcare networks were connected to production networks rather than isolated guest networks.
Gaming consoles are showing up on hospital production networks instead of segmented guest networks, according to new research from Claroty, a cyber-physical systems security company.
The report, “Game Over for Consumer Tech Risk in Critical Infrastructure,” analyzed more than 45 million devices across industrial, healthcare, and commercial networks. In healthcare, Claroty discovered 14,624 gaming consoles, and 13,939 of them (95.3%) were connected to production networks rather than to guest or internet of things networks or virtual local area networks. Another 691 (4.7%) were categorized as high risk.
“Finding consumer technology like Apple Watches and Nintendo Switches residing on the same networks as OT and medical equipment points directly to ongoing deficiencies in network governance and segmentation within operational settings,” says Sean Tufts, Field CTO at Claroty, in a release. “Addressing this issue does not mean stripping smart TVs from conference rooms or banning XBOX consoles from hospitals; it requires closing off unnecessary pathways for malicious actors from causing intolerable disruptions and negatively impacting businesses across industries.”
Claroty notes that consoles in hospitals can serve a legitimate purpose. In healthcare, the consoles were largely concentrated in children’s hospitals, where patients may request to play video games. The report says such devices should be placed on the correct guest or internet of things networks.
A Pathway for Attackers
The researchers say the concern is where the devices sit. Consumer devices are rarely designed to meet the security, reliability, and lifecycle requirements of operational environments, and many must reach out to cloud services beyond a hospital’s control. When they share infrastructure with medical devices, they can become an entry point for attackers.
Once a device is compromised, its position on the network matters, the report says. If it can communicate freely with other systems, an attacker may discover reachable assets, abuse improperly configured access permissions, steal credentials, or exploit vulnerabilities in adjacent computers and servers.
The report describes mixed-use infrastructure in which consumer devices share network space with HMIs, PLCs, MRIs, and cooling systems. Industrial settings showed a similar pattern, though on a smaller scale. Claroty found 963 gaming consoles on production operational technology networks, 862 of them (89.5%) connected to production networks instead of guest or internet of things segments.
Other consumer devices appeared on critical infrastructure networks as well. The dataset included 37,314 smart watches, 23,424 Roku streaming sticks, and 2,670 Sonos media players, and 3,425 Tesla vehicles were among the connected cars identified. Claroty reports that six critical vulnerabilities were found on Tesla Model 3 vehicles and that almost none of the vehicles were properly isolated onto guest networks.
Overall, more than 450,000 of the devices analyzed (about 3.5%) were classified as critical risk because of known vulnerabilities, outdated firmware, or a lack of security updates.
Why the Gap Persists
Claroty points to three root causes. Decentralized management lets individual sites create, modify, or ignore security rules independently, which can delay updates and create blind spots for centralized security operations centers. Legacy architectures built around perimeter-only security also struggle in connected environments. Slow modernization compounds the problem because many unsupported assets remain a critical part of process success and patient care, and replacing them is slow and expensive.
Remediation typically requires scheduled downtime, along with testing of firmware and software updates and close monitoring once they are in production.
Recommendations
Claroty calls its goal “Nintendo = Zero” and recommends that organizations:
- Implement strict network segmentation that separates guest, internet of things, and production networks with enforced policies
- Deploy continuous asset discovery for real-time visibility into connected devices
- Enforce secure access requirements to keep unauthorized devices off production networks
- Accelerate modernization by replacing legacy systems and redesigning network architectures
- Establish governance frameworks that centralize security policy while respecting operational autonomy
“Nintendo is the canary. Production and healthcare networks are the coal mine,” the report states.
ID 116230468 ยฉ Jair Fonseca | Dreamstime.com