Healthcare workers are seven times as likely to have severe COVID-19 infection as those with other types of “non-essential” jobs, finds research focusing on the first UK-wide lockdown and published online in the journal Occupational & Environmental Medicine.
Few studies have looked at the differences in the risk of developing severe COVID-19 infection between different groups of workers. While it’s known that those working in healthcare roles are at heightened risk, it’s not clear what the risks might be for those working in other sectors.
The researchers therefore compared the risk of developing severe COVID-19 infection in essential and non-essential workers, drawing on linked data from the UK Biobank study (2006-10), COVID-19 test results from Public Health England, and recorded deaths from March 16, 2020, to July 26, 2020.
The UK Biobank is a long-term study tracking the factors potentially influencing the development of disease in around half a million middle and older age adults. Severe infection was defined as a positive test result for SARS-CoV-2, the virus responsible for COVID-19, which led to a hospital stay or virus-attributable death.
The study included 120,075 employees ranging from ages 49-64. Of these, 35,127 (29%) were classified as essential workers: healthcare (9%); social care and education (11%); “other” to include police and those working in transport and food preparation (9%). Those of Black and Asian ethnicities comprised nearly 3% each of the total. They were more likely to be essential workers, as were women.
In all, 271 employees had severe COVID-19 infection. Healthcare professionals, defined as doctors and pharmacists; medical support staff; health associate professionals, defined as nurses and paramedics; and social care and transport workers had higher rates of severe COVID-19 than non-essential workers.
Compared with non-essential workers, those working in healthcare roles were more than seven times as likely to have severe infection. And those working in social care and in education were 84% as likely to do so; while “other” essential workers had a 60% higher risk of developing severe COVID-19.
When the researchers refined the employment categories further, it emerged that medical support staff were nearly nine times as likely to develop severe disease; those in social care almost 2.5 times as likely to do so and transport workers twice as likely to do so.
And when the researchers looked at the impact of ethnicity, they found that the risks of severe infection for Black and Asian non-essential workers were similar to those for white essential workers, suggesting that ethnicity is a key factor. Non-essential workers of Black and Asian backgrounds were also more than three times as likely to develop severe COVID-19 infection as white non-essential workers, while Black and Asian essential workers were more than eight times as likely to do so.
With the exception of transport workers, for whom heightened risk of severe COVID-19 infection was linked to socioeconomic status, the findings held true even after accounting for potentially influential risk factors, including lifestyle, co-existing health problems, and work patterns.
This is an observational study, and therefore can’t establish cause. And the authors acknowledge that their initial background data were collected more than a decade ago, so they were unable to account for any changes in health, lifestyle, income, and employment status. Nor were the researchers able to take account of the changes in risk over time, such as the availability of personal protective equipment (PPE). Nevertheless, the findings echo those of other studies, they point out.
“Our findings reinforce the need for adequate health and safety arrangements and provision of PPE for essential workers, especially in the health and social care sectors,” the study authors conclude. “The health and wellbeing of essential workers is critical to limiting the spread and managing the burden of global pandemics.”
